기업의 더 효율적인 소프트웨어
선택을 위한 17년 지원 경험

PTC Mathcad 사용 후기 및 리뷰

4.2 (9)

PTC Mathcad 정보

PTC Mathcad Prime을 활용하여 가장 중요한 엔지니어링 계산을 해결, 분석, 문서화 및 공유할 수 있습니다.

PTC Mathcad 자세히 알아보기

장점:

사용할 수 없음

단점:

사용할 수 없음

PTC Mathcad 등급

평균 점수

사용 편의성
4.1
고객 서비스 소프트웨어
3.8
특징
3.9
비용 대비 가치
3.8

추천 가능성

8/10

PTC Mathcad은(는) Capterra에서 9개의 사용자 리뷰를 기준으로 별 5개 중 평균 4.2점을 받았습니다.

PTC Mathcad을(를) 사용해 본 적이 있나요?

귀하의 사용 경험을 다른 소프트웨어 구매자에게 알려주세요.

리뷰 필터(9)

Muhammad
Muhammad
파키스탄의 Civil Engineer
검증된 LinkedIn 사용자
토목 공학, 11~50 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 1년 이상
리뷰어 출처

PTC Mathcad A program for every engineer

5.0 2년 전

장점:

PTC Mathcad is extremely simple and easy to use. Everyone can learn Mathcad without any extensive training or courses. The layout is simple and effective. The program is fast and reliable. Everyone should use this program for daily engineering calculations to save time and avoid errors.

단점:

PTC Mathcad lack in customised units. The software works well only when units are matching with the units that are stored in Mathcad library. There should an option added in the program to add customised units.

PTC 응답

2년 전

Hi Muhammad! Thank you for the positive review! We're happy that you love using PTC Mathcad! Regarding custom units, you can define your own custom units (documented https://support.ptc.com/help/mathcad/r8.0/en/index.html#page/PTC_Mathcad_Help/defining_units_and_unit_functions.html#wwID0ESSIGB or here in video form https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnOhPdu-NKQ ); if you would like to make units based off a unit system not in the product, please submit a feature request.

Pietro
이탈리아의 studente
기계 또는 산업 공학, 자영업
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 6~12개월
리뷰어 출처

Ideale per valutazione di massima di più soluzioni progettuali

4.0 8개월 전

장점:

Caratteristica migliore di PTC Mathcad è indubbiamente l'ambiente di lavoro intuitivo. Una volta individuate le equazioni significative per la progettazione di alcuni componenti meccanici mi è bastato riportarle sul foglio di lavoro esattamente come le avrei scritte su carta. Modificando le variabili ad inizio documento mi è stato possibile, grazie al calcolo automatico, valutare come differenti scelte progettuali incidessero sulla riuscita del progetto stesso.

단점:

Il software ha meno potenza di calcolo rispetto ad altri i quali però richiedono una trascrizione delle equazioni meno intuitiva. Ciò comporta più lente procedure di calcolo su documenti molto articolati.

PTC 응답

8개월 전

Thank you for your review!

Jan
미국의 Cook & Bottle Washer
전기/전자 제조, 201~500 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 6~12개월
리뷰어 출처
출처: SoftwareAdvice

PTC - The Ruination of Mathcad

1.0 3년 전

주석: PTC has ruined one of the best programs ever. There was a substitute of sorts, the Svientific Notebook program. However, that company went out of business in 2021.

장점:

Mathcad under Mathsoft was the engineers friend.

단점:

Since PTC acquired Mathsoft, users have endured forced upgrades, incompatible legacy worksheets, and outrageous price hikes.

검증된 리뷰어
검증된 LinkedIn 사용자
토목 공학, 51~200 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 6~12개월
리뷰어 출처

Nice for formatting but I still prefer excel

4.0 2년 전

장점:

The format in which the calculations come are consistent

단점:

It lacks a lot of functionalities that excel gives like linking cells

PTC 응답

2년 전

Thank you for your review. We are sorry to hear that you still prefer Excel to Mathcad for engineering calculations. With regards to linking cells (and most other relevant calculation areas), Mathcad Prime absolutely has Excel-esque capabilities, if not better. You can use the Definition operator to define variables or functions, and you can then use that definition across your worksheet, much like a linked cell in Excel. When you change the value of a definition, that change propagates to everywhere else the definition is used. In addition, you can reference other worksheets' definitions by using Mathcad's Include Worksheet feature, which is akin to how to link cells between different Excel worksheets. With regards to other lacking functionality, please request that missing functionality on the PTC Community Mathcad Ideas board so our team can document it and implement it to make Mathcad Prime a better product to serve your needs. Again, thank you for your review.

Daniel
에콰도르의 University Intern
전기/전자 제조, 1,001~5,000 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 1년 이상
리뷰어 출처

The replacement to spreadsheets, PTC Mathcad

4.0 작년

주석: I used it to present several papers, and I liked the way the worksheet is customizable, and it looked like a real checkered sheets, besides, you didn't have to have a calculator or an Excel sheet next to you, since all the calculations were done by the program. However, I never found an option to place formulas in a presentation way, so I had to do it in external software and add them in image format.

장점:

Presentation and order is the main strength of PTC Mathcad, as it is the perfect combination of Word and Excel. On a sheet (of set sizes), you can place Titles, Subtitles, text in general; and most importantly, mathematical formulas. That, the same software performs the calculations to solve different engineering problems. And in the same way these data can be represented in tables or graphs that are elaborated with tools integrated with the program.

단점:

It is very difficult to present an unresolved formula in Mathcad, that is to say, when placing a formula without declared variables, they are painted red, indicating that this formula is an error, and this error when passing it to a PDF document, continues to be visible, being annoying.

PTC 응답

작년

Thanks for enjoying PTC Mathcad! One trick to present formulas in a presentation way without evaluating them is to use the "Equal To" operator. (Ctrl + =)

Cloency
미국의 Test Engineer
항공사/항공, 201~500 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 2년 이상
리뷰어 출처

A Must-Have for Engineering Students

5.0 3년 전

장점:

Mathcad is a great engineering analysis tool that is can be handily used with its partner software PTC CREO (formerly Pro/E). This integration is key to understanding the fundamentals of basic engineering like stress analysis and thermal analysis.

단점:

Mathcad can be a bit taxing when working with Creo or other engineering software. It is amazing software nevertheless.

PTC 응답

3년 전

Thank you for your review!

검증된 리뷰어
검증된 LinkedIn 사용자
기계 또는 산업 공학, 501~1,000 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 1~5개월
리뷰어 출처

One of my favourite mathematical software

5.0 4년 전

주석: I love it. Totally recommended. You can use it for almost everything!!

장점:

This software is so easy to use. You do not need to learn any programming language, it has several options. I still get surprised when I find a new feature. I love it.

단점:

I have used the Mathcad 15 and sometimes I found that version simplier. Recently, I tried to make a 3D surface plot and was hard to customize it compared to Mathcad 15

PTC 응답

4년 전

Thank you!

검증된 리뷰어
검증된 LinkedIn 사용자
자동차, 501~1,000 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 2년 이상
리뷰어 출처

Review: PTC Mathcad

5.0 2년 전

장점:

1. Comparatively easy to write detailed engineering worksheets.2. Complex mathematical expressions can be written in an expanded form which facilitates the verification.

단점:

Picture add-in feature can be improved.Overlapping of pictures over texts should be prevented automatically.

Antonio
이탈리아의 Engineering Dept Head
항공 및 항공 우주, 11~50 직원
소프트웨어 사용 목적: 무료 체험판
리뷰어 출처

Mathcad experience

5.0 3년 전

주석: I met this SW at University and I still love it.

장점:

Like an hand worksheet with the innovative feature of showing variable dimensions i.e.: metre, lb, N and so on so you don't need to check for analytical model consistency.

단점:

It's an amazing and effecient tools for any engineer.