CHEMCAD 사용 후기 및 리뷰

Very useful for chemical engineers and process teaching

장점:

Easy to use and very useful for the learning of chemical processes, especially for students of chemical engineering and professionals in the area

단점:

Many students fell behind in the semester because they did not understand their application despite being simple

CHEMCAD: Might take some time but is Versatile

주석: It is very useful software and being a chemical engineer I have used it frequently throughout my bachelors in plant design projects and with no doubt I would recommend Chemcad for the process simulation.

장점:

Chemcad is software specially dedicated to the chemical engineers for the process simulation. While it might be difficult for the beginners to understand the interface, once you get soaked in you can make a really good use of it. Chemcad comes up with numbers of features like equipment sizing, equipment design and process economics as well. Also it includes thermophysical calculations. With all those features, it definitely helps engineers from designing a equipment to designing the whole plant as well as performing other calculations too. One might say that other application are better than this, I would definitely argue with that for the fact that it is great value for money

단점:

As mentioned earlier, this software might be quite difficult at the beginning because the interface is confusing but there are lots of tutorials and webinars held that will help you to learn. Furthermore, in case of any errors or unexpected results, you have to sort out for the problems manually as the program won’t do itself.

While Chemcad is a great simulation tool, it is slow, crashes easily, and is extremely sensitive.

장점:

For processes that are not too complex, this software is easy to pick up on.

단점:

Process design with multiple unit operations is extremely difficult and Chemcad rarely converges. Little to no troubleshooting available.

A great tool for the every day chemist.

주석: Is the best option for analytical chemistry out there

장점:

Without a doubt is one of the most practical softwares in analytical chemistry, it has a lot a features, and you can handle your equipment and do the interpretation all in the same software. Also it's easy to write macros and change the features you find complicated.

단점:

It takes a great time to master the software, there in a lot of the versions the manage of the signal is very hard and the help assume you know very practical things in the equipment and the software it self.

Great way to understand chemical dynamics

주석: Great chemical engineering software that allows studying chemical processes at a wide range of levels.

장점:

Use of this software is very intuitive. Simpler chemical reactions are readily set up and the dynamics and thermodynamics of those reactions accessible right away for study.

단점:

For the moment, the level of this software is too advanced for my needs. I am confident that I will eventually take advantage of many more of its capabilities, but for now the advanced capabilities confuse my analyses sometimes.

Great engineering software for use in teaching chemical process design (and for use in design)

주석: This taught me and my classmates a lot about process design engineering and was a great tool to take many chemical engineering skills and apply them to real life. The online help was also very helpful for topics that may not have been covered in class.

장점:

This software works well for chemical process modeling, and was used at my university to teach design to senior design. It had many features that worked well for the course, and basically had everything necessary for us to complete our design project and learn what we needed to. I can definitely see uses in industry as this project gave us a good background on what we could expect with process engineering or process design roles.

단점:

It can be difficult to learn, and some people fell behind throughout the semester. Unfortunately, there may not be much that can be done about this. In fact, there are a lot of tutorials and helpful advice on the website, and even some workshops. The toughness just comes from the rigor from chemical engineering in the first place. Some may argue that alternative chemical process design software may be better, but it really is not much better than this in my opinion.

Powerful software for chemical process design but has its limitations

주석: Used to determine and verify design requirements for chemical reactor equipment.

장점:

Reactor design functions. Can choose from a catalog of reactants, choose the features that you want and it will give a required reactor size that you would need to achieve your desired results. Can also design heat exchangers, distillation columns, adsorption columns, pumps, ect.

단점:

Does not screen for feasibility. This software can only work with the inputs that you give it. So you will have to screen for unreasonable and unexpected results. This only really should be a tool for getting a general idea of plans and should not be the exact plans for any piece of equipment.

simulation

주석: overall easier to use than similar programs. For this reason, using this program as an exercise will contribute to the general simulation rules.

장점:

first of all it is very easy to use and find detailed explanations. This is the most important advantage. If you are doing simulation for the first time, it is definitely a very important program for you.

단점:

In my simulations, the program sometimes gives very illogical errors and this affects the reliability of my result. The database needs to be updated and developed.

Excellent simulation software for simple chemical reactions.

장점:

1. It can be easily installed. 2. Great user interface. 3. Easy to create new process designs. 4. Extremely adaptable when picking up new chemical interactions. 5. Increases students' ability for learning and drawing reaction mechanisms. 6. Enables to create excellent graphical abstract.

단점:

1. It is quite sensitive, sluggish. 2. It crashes suddenly.

Chemcad's Analisys

주석: I was excellent, I managed to perform the necessary simulation, however, understanding the graphical interface some time is lost

장점:

It is excellent for the simulation of food industry processes, such as multireaction petrochemical processes, since it allows the inclusion of the performance and selectivity data

단점:

I did not like graphic interdaz, it's unfriendly for a beginner. It should be more didactic, additional there is not much availability of information about the simulator.

Universell nutzbar in der Verfahrentechnik

주석: Sehr gut

장점:

Große Stoffdatenbank, viele Unit Operations, einfache Bedienung, exaktes Ergebnis, kurze Rechenzeiten, kompatibel zu Excel und VBA

단점:

Irgendwas fehlt immer. In einem solchen Fall hilft die Excel-Unit, deren Algorithmus man leicht selbst erstellen kann.

Simple and Easy to Learn Software

주석: Overall, very happy with using Chemcad at my small company, allowing us to simulate chemical engineering processes easily.

장점:

I love how easy it was to learn how to use this software -- modeling the chemical reactions/components we need took very little time.

단점:

The license was fairly expensive, but it seems to be worth it -- it speeds up our modeling time significantly.

Chemcad Improves My Efficiency

주석: Overall, my switch to using Chemcad has allowed me to work much more quickly through similar projects, all while automating much of the calculations I previously had to do by hand.

장점:

The Process Flow Diagram editor is a life saver, and is the most useful part of the software for me. It saves tons of time compared to similar software packages.

단점:

There was some learning curve to moving from manual to software based diagrams, but the time to learn was definitely worth it. Automatic calculations save lots of time and brain power.

Chemcad review

주석: The software can be used for modelling referigerative cycles

장점:

Provides a nice environment for steady state simulations .

단점:

Converging of flowsheets with recycling is a bit difficult.

Very easy process designing; includes all the tools needed

장점:

I was able to apply my chemical engineering education with this software. Most of the components I learned about were there to apply to my designs and I was able to map out the plant design for my colleagues without much training.

단점:

The user interface seems a little outdated, but I noticed that with pretty much all software I have used in this sector.

Simulation and design software useful to chemical engineers

주석: Learned the basics and was able to do a few projects. Would be worth learning more advanced features.

장점:

Very helpful for chemical process design. Getting up to speed is simple and more advanced simulation features.

단점:

Other software for simulation that seemed more valuable to learn. Once we learned basics in ChemCad we were using other process software.

Great software for calculating everything you need for your process

장점:

Very simple with many different unit ops. Thermodynamic models seem to be accurate and effective. Easy to use

단점:

Appearance is old looking compared to other flowsheeting software. There needs to be more cost calculating functionality

Good use for simpler chemical processes

장점:

Interesting software for chemical process design. Good use for simpler chemical processes

단점:

What I least like is the fact that it takes to converge in multiple processes

A very customizable tool

장점:

Chemcad has the great advantage of having varied and full-function modules for different types of processes and industries. This, in addition to allowing the customization of the software with independent modules that work together according to the needs of each client.

단점:

Being a chemical software with so many functionalities makes Chemcad a complex management software for apprentices. However, there are tutorials and examples on the web that can help with this aspect.